Nickel Steamroller: An Alternative to Lendstats for Lending Club Investors

My post on Friday about the shut down of Lendstats has generated a lot of comments. I have also had many emails from concerned investors, some who are thinking of no longer investing without access to the kind of information that Lendstats provides.

The good news is that there is an alternative out there, one that has been running for about a year now. It is called NickelSteamroller.com and it provides all the data that Lendstats provided but as of today it is only available for Lending Club investors. Michael, the creator of Nickel Steamroller is also an investor in Prosper and he would love to have a tool for them but he is waiting for Prosper to provide some additional pieces of information in their data download. This should happen in the very near future I have been told.

For now, though, Lending Club investors can switch to Nickel Steamroller and do their analysis there. There is a lot of information on Nickel Steamroller and I encourage you to spend some time exploring the site. The one part I am focusing on today is the Lending Club Return Forecaster which provides the same data as the Lending Club stats page on Lendstats. The implementation is a little different and there are even some additional features.

Introductory Video For NickelSteamroller.com

To show p2p investors how Nickel Steamroller works I have created this short video that shows everyone how to setup the filtering. As an example I use my Lending Club Filter 1 that I defined in my How am I Investing in 2012 post. This video is just for Lending Club investors, when the Prosper data is available I will do another video.

Prosper Investors Should Stay Tuned

I have spoken with Joe Toms, Chief Investment Officer, at Prosper today and he assures me that the data that Michael desires will be available soon. So Prosper investors shouldn’t have long to wait before there is robust analysis on the loan history.

Subscribe
Notify of
20 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Michael
Jul. 16, 2012 5:44 pm

Peter, thanks for the great video.

Tim
Tim
Jul. 17, 2012 8:23 am

Peter, thanks for the video. I just wish I had more money in this account to invest.

I do have some newby jitters…wondering what the heck I have gotten myself into!

As I continue to read everything I can get my hands on related to p2p lending, I am finding that it would have probably been better if I had taken it a bit more slowly with buying notes. I currently have 200 notes. I didn’t want a lot of money sitting around doing nothing.

I was a bit more conservative than you in that I tried to stay with 36 month notes and I tried to stay with the better grades at least initially. I stayed away from the state of CA completely. I tried to stay with higher incomes and good work history. I did 0 on public filings and no more than 1 inquiry in the past 6 months. I have 52% in grade “B,” 18% in grade “A,” 17% in grade “C,” 8% in grade “D,” 4% in grade “E” and 1% in grade “F.” When I get some profit under me, I will take a riskier position.

This is a traditional IRA account that I just started about a month ago. At this time, no payments are due until next week. I hope this goes well and I do plan to go for 800 notes (at least). Any advise at this time?

Regards,

Tim Gibson

BNL
BNL
Jul. 17, 2012 12:58 pm

Thanks for sharing this, Peter. I was a little caught off guard when Lendstats went down, and disappointed too, but NSR’s filter looks very promising.

If I sign up for email alerts, dows this mean I will be emailed occasionally on what loans are now In Funding under one of my saved search criteria? That’s a key piece that I didn’t see in the NSR filter that Lendstats did so nicely. It made it very fast and easy to reinvest.

Danny S
Danny S
Jul. 18, 2012 1:10 pm

I dont use Prosper so it doesnt affect me personally, but I do hope either Nickel or other websites offer similar tools to Prosper investors soon.

Michael
Jul. 18, 2012 4:13 pm
Reply to  Danny S

@Danny S – I have all the code ready to go for Prosper. I just need a few data elements added to their export. I hope to have support for Prosper very soon. I am a Prosper investor myself.

Bilgefisher
Jul. 19, 2012 7:51 am

Michael,

I look forward to testing using what you have available for prosper. Take the right steps and your website could be a driving force in the industry. Not many people can say their product is a driving force in a billion dollar industry,

Jason

Rocco
Rocco
Jul. 21, 2012 3:24 pm

Peter,
Thanks for posting the Introductory Video For NickelSteamroller.com. I’ll need to spend more time poking around on their site. However, at a glance it seems to have similar functionality as Lendstats.
Cheers
Rocco

CA-Lender
CA-Lender
Jul. 26, 2012 8:27 am

What effect do you think will be on Prosper’s July loans number without Lendstats?

Right now, they are at 1552 loans and $11.7M. Looks like they are going to struggle a bit to beat the $13.6M from June (even with the extra day in July). They’ve beaten month over month new loan funded for 22 months. I do think they will end up beating June, (so they can continue the streak) but it’ll probably be very close ($13.7M), and at what expense (extra bonuses)?

A few days ago Prosper offered the “2% bonus promo” for investing in Featured notes, and some/most of the featured notes were C,D,E and HR, which I haven’t seen in months (probably in all of 2012).

Just wonder if this is a coincidence or if lendstats disconnecting his filtering service is having a material affect on Prosper funding new loans.

CA-Lender

PS—For the last 45 days, every note I invested in was from the lendstats site using the top 10 ROI investors, and just investing in notes that they invested in (as well as SNL-10’s notes) so this affected my volume of new investments in June.

Raymond
Raymond
Jan. 28, 2013 11:50 am

Lending Club Return Forecaster of NickelSteamroller.com is not good to use. It seems to me that the calculation of return is using the whole loan amount. I think it is not useful for us the lender. I only care about the loan fraction I purchased, no matter its a $20000 loan or $6000 loan. The calculation should assume that each loan have a fixed value, such as $25 for the lender, otherwise, the return rate calculated is not meaningful for us the lender.

Michael
Jan. 28, 2013 12:22 pm
Reply to  Raymond

Raymond. I can add a “set all loans” equal check box and scale the loans to 1000 behind the scenes. I’ll update you when this is done. I hope that will help you.

Michael
Jan. 28, 2013 12:48 pm
Reply to  Raymond

Raymond, I added a check box to the ROI forecaster to do as you desired. If there is anything else you would like to see, don’t hesitate to contact me. Thanks.

Raymond Guo
Raymond Guo
Jan. 28, 2013 8:48 pm
Reply to  Michael

Michael, it’s great that you added the option. Thanks! Could you please allow input of time range on month basis, such as 04/2011 to 04/2012? I am always more interested to check loans in a one-year-range which is 10 months ago to update my loan filters.

Michael
Jan. 28, 2013 9:36 pm
Reply to  Raymond Guo

Do you want the day in there too? I think it’s good to add a little more resolution to the vintage ranges, so I am glad you requested it. I can limit it to month and year, or additionally include the day as well. I would argue the day of the month would offer little advantage. Thoughts?

Michael
Jan. 28, 2013 10:10 pm
Reply to  Raymond Guo

I added the year and month, I left the day off. However, I want to state for the record that leap years and of the months days are automatically detected. The month is inclusive of the range. I hope this is easy to use, if its not, let me know and I will make the recommended changes.

Raymond Guo
Raymond Guo
Jan. 28, 2013 10:36 pm
Reply to  Michael

Wooo, your update is so prompt. Appreciated. A question regarding to “Total Amount Funded”. My suggestion is use “Loan Amount” requested instead. The reason is that when I search the loans, Loan Amount is more important, obvious and unchanged data.
Additional filter which I am interest in:
1) “Credit History” which I define as current year – earliest credit line (year).
2) Monthly payment / Monthly income. Do not want it to be too high.
3) Number of days taken to funded the loan. Not sure if the data feed has this piece of data or not. I heard that loans which taked more than 10 days to be funded are more likely default, and I would like to verify that.

By the way, could you share how the default rate and return rate calculated, so I can better understand the result?

Have a great night.